I think it is very important
to record one's sources of information when publishing any genealogical
data. I have been frustrated over the years, as I am sure you have
been, by finding interesting details recorded here and there in old family
papers without any indication of where the information was obtained.
Of course, it was much more difficult and time-consuming in the pen and
paper era to ascribe a source to every piece of information and my forebears
can be forgiven for not having done so but there is absolutely no excuse
now that excellent genealogical databases are freely available for use
on personal computers .
My grandfather, Richard James Green, was a keen genealogist who spent
about
30 years accumulating family information which he recorded
in a fine hand in a book which he called "The House of Green". Only
very occasionally, in this extensive work, is there any mention of where
he obtained the information that he records. From the correspondence
and documents that have survived, it seems that he did little original
research himself and relied instead on information obtained from other
family members or from books.
"The House of Green" has been invaluable to me in creating the various
family details that make up these web pages but from the start I set out
to verify all the dates, relationships, etc., that it records. I
have done this, wherever possible, by going back to original documents such
as parish or civil registers, newspaper notices, Wills and so on.
Of course, it has not always been either possible or practicable to
verify every piece of information that I have obtained from the many family
sources, apart from "The House of Green", which have helped me build this
family record, particularly when the original source is in some distant country.
Nevertheless, I have tried to ascribe a source to everything that I have
recorded even if, in some cases, that source is entirely unverified, believing
as I do that any attribution is better than none!
One final point. Beware of transcriptions,
very useful though they are! Old records, when difficult to read, often
give rise to misreadings or misinterpretations. Moreover, entries that
are very difficult to read are sometimes skipped altogether. This problem
with transcriptions is as true of the International Genealogical Index as
it is for those compiled by local genealogists; so do always check the original
source whenever you can.
J. R. U. Green
|